The Skin

Last updated (19 November 2003)

Pigmented Click on the image to download a larger version
The excision with 2 cm margins again confirms the findings of melanoma on punch biopsy. The Breslow thickness is 7 mm and Clarkes level is five.
How should the regional nodes be managed?
Bloc dissection of the left supraclavicular nodes.
Bloc dissection of the left axiallary nodes.
MRI or PET scanning with FNA or excisional biopsy followed by block dissection if they are suspicious.
Sentinal node biopsy at the time of excsion of the primary tumor.
Careful clinical follow up.

The answer

Either a sentinal node biopsy using blue dye and a radio-isotope or careful clinical follow up would be appropriate.

Small Print

In a melanoma such as this management of the regional nodes is difficult.

The lymphatic drainage of the skin on the medial side of the scapula could be to the ipsilateral supraclavicular fossa, the ipsilateral axilla, the ipsilateral mid trunk node or indeed it could drain to the contralateral side.

This unpredictability of drainage makes a best guess approach akin to the battleships board game. You may hit the right basin, but then again you may not.

A further problem is the morbidity associated with radical excision of the lymph node basin, in particular the axillary basin, which may result in upper limb lymph-oedema.

Yet another reservation is lack of evidence of benefit to the patient with melanoma from elective lymph node dissection.

However, lymphatic metastases do offer prognostic information. If there is no evidence of lymphatic metastatic disease the patient may be reassured.

For these reasons, sentinal node techniques are becoming attractive. They combine a minimal surgical approach (lower morbidity), with accurate identification of the first draining node (no battleships). The node may be examined pathologically and decisions regarding block dissection made on the basis of the sentinal node result.

It seems however, that the sentinal node technique has introduced new complexities.


Adrian P. Ireland