The Skin

Last updated (19 November 2003)

Pigmented Click on the image to download a larger version
The lesion is clinically suspeicious for a melanoma. How would you confirm the diagnosis?
Perform skin scrapings
Do an MRI
Do an excisional biopsy
Do a punch biopsy

The answer

The clinical suspicion can be readily confirmed by a punch biopsy.

What the student may say

The first thing to do is a full history and clinical examination. In particular I would enquire about a past history of any cancers, the family history, occupation (indoors or outdoors) and history of sunburn. On examination, I would carefully look for evidence of metastatic disease in particular in the adjacent lymph node basins, the supraclavicular fossa, both axillae and in the mid lateral trunk. I would carefully inspect the skin between the lesion and these lymph node basins to look for in-transit metastases.

There is no blood test that would be of any particular interest. Detailed scanning should be avoided untill the suspected diagnosis is confirmed. A CXR may be worth while however.

The diagnosis is most readily confirmed by a punch biopsy. An excisional biopsy could be considered if the lesion was smaller but in this case excision would not be feasible without embarking on elaborate reconstruction.

Small print

Skin scrapings (and nail clippings) are usually performed to check for fungal infection.

An MRI may be used to stage melanomas and other tumors but is usually not used to confirm the diagnosis. The most important modality to confirm the nature of an abnormality is tissue diagnosis which depends on tissue.

Excisional biopsy could be considered but the large size of the lesion means that primary closure would not be possible and the defect would then require closure with some more elaborate means. Following definitive diagnosis with tissue then a larger excision and further elaborate means again would be needed to cover the defect.


Adrian P. Ireland